“We Condemn the AMA and AAMC Endorsements of Tom Price for HHS Secretary”

SNaHP Icon

“As students and future health care professionals, we are deeply troubled by the AMA and AAMC endorsements of Rep. Price.”

Early Tuesday morning, President-elect Donald Trump announced his selection of Representative Tom Price (R-Ga.) for Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS), to succeed Secretary Sylvia Mathews Burwell. Almost immediately, the American Medical Association (AMA) and Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) expressed strong support for this nomination.

As students and future health care professionals, we are deeply troubled by the AMA and AAMC endorsements of Rep. Price. The policies he has endorsed not only stand in stark contrast to our ideals, but also threaten the well-being of our patients. We question why these organizations—established to protect the interests of all physicians, students, patients, and communities—would ignore the priorities of those they represent. As HHS secretary, Dr. Price will endanger medical institutions and policies, as well as jeopardize our medical education and the very practice of evidence-based medicine.

Though Price, an orthopedic surgeon, claims to prioritize patient, family, and physician needs, his track record suggests decidedly otherwise. In 2015, as leader of the House Budget Committee, he proposed repealing the Affordable Care Act (ACA) in its entirety, privatizing Medicare, making enormous cuts to federal Medicaid funding, and abolishing the mandate that states use Medicaid dollars for patient care. These proposals would guarantee an immediate loss of health insurance for 22 million Americans; increase health care costs for the aged and disabled; and reverse recently-gained protections for vulnerable members of our society, abolishing protections of women’s health, addiction, LGBTQ+, and other necessary medical services.

Despite evidence of the substantial harm his policies would inflict upon patients, Rep. Price continues to advocate for them in his fiscal plan for 2017, promising to destroy the systems already in place to protect the neediest among us and placing the health of millions of Americans at risk.

The AMA’s support of Price lies in direct conflict with the organization’s purported values and its mission “to promote the art and science of medicine and the betterment of public health.” If the AMA is truly committed to promoting the science of medicine, it must recognize that this country cannot afford to place power in the hands of a man who opposes promising scientific breakthroughs like embryonic stem cell research. Similarly, it must ensure that the nation’s HHS secretary values the truth. On the contrary, Rep. Price has demonstrated a severe lack of respect for facts, exemplified by his false claims that women have always been able to afford birth control, and that “not one” has benefited from the ACA’s contraceptive mandate.

If the AMA is truly concerned about the betterment of public health, it is frankly irresponsible to endorse a nominee who wants to decimate Medicaid—which serves more than 70 million Americans who cannot otherwise afford care—and privatize Medicare, creating narrow networks for enrollees, making seniors increasingly responsible for their health expenses, and decreasing access to needed care.

We find the AMA’s paradoxical endorsement objectionable, but unsurprising. This would not be the first time the organization has acted in the interest of profits over patients; it supported the ACA only begrudgingly, and has historically blocked every effort for universal health care reform, despite evidence of the innumerable benefits that a Medicare-for-All system would afford patients and providers alike. While the AMA has failed to represent the priorities and values of its member physicians for decades, the situation at hand poses too great a danger to our nation’s health for the medical community to remain silent.

The AAMC’s endorsement of Price is equally, if not more disturbing, given its role in molding future physicians and its mission to “serve and lead the academic medicine community to improve the health of all.” In its endorsement, the AAMC claims that Price “has long been a proponent of academic medicine.” This blatantly ignores the fact that the financial solvency of most academic medical centers depends directly on Medicare and Medicaid payments, given that individuals covered by these programs comprise a large percentage of those receiving care at these institutions. Without these programs, academic medicine as we know it would cease to exist.

If the AAMC truly wishes to “improve the health of all,” it cannot reasonably justify endorsing the nomination of a man who would strip 22 million people of health insurance, who has vocally opposed expanding health benefits for children, who believes our government has no responsibility to provide coverage to transgender individuals, and who ignores substantial evidence that access to preventative screenings, contraception, and abortion services have overwhelmingly positive impacts on women’s health.

As medical students and physicians, we condemn the AMA and AAMC endorsements of Price for HHS secretary, and are disheartened by professional organizations like the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) and others choosing to follow suit. Price’s stances are incompatible with the values of the medical profession and with the stated missions of the above organizations. Their support reveals a warped set of priorities, with the short-term professional and financial interests of hospitals and physicians superseding the health and wellbeing of patients. We staunchly reject these endorsements and urge their immediate withdrawal.

In endorsing Price’s nomination and contravening their founding principles, the AMA and AAMC have failed to represent us, the future health care providers of this country. As members and supporters of Students for a National Health Program (SNaHP), we will combat every attempt to deny Americans the health care they deserve, and will fight to create a single-payer health care system that covers every person living in this country without discrimination. If the AMA and AAMC truly believe in their own missions, we urge them to join us in this fight.

Please consider adding your name to our statement to show your support in our condemnation of the AMA, AAMC, and others who endorse the nomination of Rep. Price for Secretary of Health and Human Services.

Janine Petito is a fourth-year medical student at Boston University School of Medicine, who plans to complete residency in internal medicine and pursue a career in adult primary care. She is co-chair of the Students for a National Health Program (SNaHP) Political Advocacy Team and a Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP) student board member.

Andrew Hyatt is a third-year medical student at Boston University School of Medicine, an active member of Students for a National Health Program (SNaHP), and co-chair of the SNaHP Political Advocacy Team.

Michael Zingman is a first-year student at Columbia College of Physicians & Surgeons and active member of Students for a National Health Program (SNaHP).

If you would like to add your name to this list, click on this link:


(U.S. government employee who fears retaliation)
Aaron Eisman
Adam Morgan
Adam Weissman
Agma Prins
Agnoli Agnoli
Aimee McMullin
Ajay Koti
Akshar Rambachan
Alan Meyers
Alan Miller, MD
Alap Shah
Alex Bowman
Alex Iwamoto
Alex Sun
Alexander Rochelle
Alexandra Wong
Alice Rothchild
Alice Tang
Alice Wei
Alison Liss
Alissa Correll
Allan Guiney
Allan Guiney
Allen Cooper
Allison Blumenfeld
Alyssa McFarland
Amanda Malik
Amanda West
Amy Levi
Amy Marietta
Anand Saha
Andrea Lui
Andrew Levitas
Andrew Olsen
Andy Hyatt
Anita Hulsey
Anna Chollet
Anne Caywood
Anne Flanagan
Anne Marie Williams
Anne Scheetz
Anne Weinlich Miltenberg
Anne-Marie Giuca
Annie Harriman
Annie Shideler
Anthony Newfield
Anthony Schlaff
Ari Epstein
Arielle Hirschfeld
Armide Storey
Arthur Grant
Aubrey McMillan
Audrey French
Audrey Stillerman
Austin McCullough
Barbara Lukert
Barbara Sarah
Barbara Schnoor
Barry Zingman, MD
Barton Schoenfeld
Benjamin Wagner
Benji Dossetter
Betsy Pepper, MD
Beverly Alves
Bob Lippitt
Brad Cotton, MD
Brad Zehr
Braidie Campbell
Brandi Heinz
Brian Kroener
Brian White
Brittany Anderson
Bruce Rosen
Bruce Stanley Willenbring
Bryant Shuey
C. Lee Cohen
C. Wesley Dingman
Caitlin Colling
Caitrin Kelly, MD
Cameron Moore
Carla Castillo
Carla Gates
Carla Harrigan
Carlton Lawrence
Carmen Albizu-Garcia
Carol Feng
Carol Paris, MD
Carol Ryan
Caroline Kistin, MD
Carolyn Becker
Caryl Heaton
Casey Fein
Catherine Myers, MD
Cathy Canepa
Charlene Gaw
Charles Mackin
Charles Surette
Charlotte Taft
Chelsea Messinger
Chris Wheeler
Christine Krueger
Christopher Hyson
Christopher O’Brien
Claire Brickson
Claudia Balderrama
Clyde Lanford Smith
Colleen Andrews
Colleen Christmas
Collin Shumate
Constancia Romilly
Corinne Frugoni
Courtney Caminiti
Cynthia Ingraham
Cynthia Susai
Dani Baurer
Daniel Aldea
Daniel Brook
Daniel Lugassy
Daniel Mueller
Daniel Neuspiel
Daniel Piening
Daniel Sorkin
Daniel Yohanna, M.D.
Danielle Loeb
Danika Barry
Darcy Goldfarb
Dave Sprague
David Bor
David Flood
David Goldberg
David Mair
David S. Krantz, Ph.D.
David Walters
Dawn Fishbein
Deborah Levin
Debra Eisemann
Debra Klamen
Denise Burns
Denise Burns
Dennis Hart
Derek Barisas
Desiree Clement
Devki Joshi
Diana LaMar
Diana Wohler
Diane Kirschner
Dianne Reinhardt
Dinah Applewhite
DJ Smithers
Doug Bullock
Douglas DiCola
Drew Griffin
Dylan Streb
E Iliaki
Edward Bender
Eiftu Haile
Elaine Fox
Eleanor Emery
Elena Hogenesch
Elizabeth Doty
Elizabeth Feldman
Elizabeth Maxwell, MD
Elizabeth McKenna
Elizabeth Rosenthal
Elizabeth Stranges
Ellen Mason
Emily Aaronson
Emily Geldwert
Emily Horn
Emily John
Emily Kirchner
Emma Murphy
Emma Richardson
Emma Richardson
Emma Sandoe
Erika Yeomans
Erin Jurich-Finney, MD
Evelyn Pasillas
Ezra Lyon
Faiz Khan
Frank Bienkowski
Fred Kinsey
Frederick Dalgleish
Frederick Milgrim
Fredrick Orkin
Gabrielle Horner
Garrett Bowen
Gene Bishop
Geniene Wilson, MD
Gordon Schiff
Grace Chao
Grant Campbell
Greta Braun
Grey Faulkenberry
Gwendolyn Chambrun
Hal Snyder
Hannah Kazal
Harleigh Boldridge
Harold Appel
Hau Phan
Heather Sweeney
Helen Jack
Helen Meltzer-Krim
Henry Kietzman
Henry Moss, PhD
Henry Schwimmer
Herbert Goldman
Herbert Goldman
Holly Scherzi
Hope DeRogatis
Horace Rhodes Hambrick
Howard Lanney
Hugo Carmona
I Harwayne-Gidansky
Ian Hsu
Ingegerd Enacoe
Ingrid Pratt
Iru Fernando
J Doyle
J Sinkinson
Jack Kotecki
Jack Simel
Jackline Joy Lasola
Jacob Refer
Jacqui Henrich
James Hudspeth
Jane A  Petro, MD, FACS, FAACS
Janet Harmon
Janet Ho
Janine Petito
Jared Goldberg
Jawad Husain
Jay Bowman-Kirigin
Jeanette Comstock
Jeanne Beddoe
jeffrey Freilich
Jeffrey Stein
Jen Hayashi
Jennifer Adams
Jennifer Leahy
Jennifer Tsai
Jenny Siegel, MD
Jeoffry Gordon
Jeremy Mosher
Jessamyn Blau
Jessica Kraker
Jillian Caldwell
Jo Henderson-Frost
Joan O’Brien
Joanne Throne
Joe Hodgkin
John Stickle, MD
John Whipple
Jonathan Gomez
Jonathan Michels
Jonathan Pickos
Jonathan Steer
Joseph Mega
Joshua Doppelt
Joshua Freeman
Joshua Page
Josie Fisher
Joy Cambe
Judith Brook
Judith Frank
Judy Margo
Julia Gelissen
Julia Solomon
Julianne Edwards
Julie Day
Julie Wegener
K. Allen Greiner
Kali Kramolis
Karen Foo
Karen Hoover
Karin Porter-Williamson
Karl Koessel
Kate de Klerk
Katelin Blackburn
Katherine Allen
Katherine C. Bini
Katherine Howard
Katherine Jahnes, MD
Katherine Palmer
Katherine Sakmar
Katherine Shelton
Katherine Valles
Kathleen Chung
Kathleen Joseph
Kathleen Nolan
Kathryn Eszes
Kathryn Hoffman
Kaushal Vaidya
Kelly Nelson
Kelsey Green
Kelsey Sullivan
Keri Metcalf
Keri-Lee Garel
Kevin Byrne
Kevin Carey
Kimberly Narain
Kimberly Sue
Kirsten Austad
Kreis Christophe
Kysa McSky
Lakshmi Sundaresan
Lance Whitehair
Lane Trippe
Lara Chelian
Laura Ha
Laura Steenberge
Lauren Wolchok
Lawrence Gross
Lenne Miller
Leonard Hickman
leslie Gise
Licia Williams
Linda Holland
Linda Kleinhenz, OD
Linda Liu
Linda Sharp
Lipika Samal
Lisa Buck
Lisa Olmsted
Lisa Phillips
Lisa Souke
Lisa Tipton
Liz Grasser
Liza Goldman Huertas
Lucila Suarez
Lydia Lo
M Fokas
Maalika Banerjee
MacKenzie Brigham
Madeline O’Connor
Maggie Sullivan
Maha Haqqani
Mallika Govindan
Mani Vahidi
Mara Lavitt
Marc H Lavietes
Marcel Bertsch-Gout
Marcia Johnson
Marcia Katz
Mardge Cohen, MD
Margaret Axelrod
Margaret Baylson
Margaret Levitt
Margaret McCarthy
Margaret Russell
Margaret Smith
Marguerite Youngren
Maria Schiaffino
Maria Schmidt
Maria Walenesky Medina
Marie Schneider
Marilyn Simons
Mark Anthony
Mark Eisenberg, MD
Mark Herzog
Mark Lamb
Mark Morales
Martha Knutsen, MD
Martin Mendelson
Mary Campbell
Mary Patton
MaryAnn Dakkak
Matt Guerrieri
Matthew Pius
Maureen Gang
Meg Mazzeo
Melissa Dattalo
Melissa Greenspan
Melissa Palma
Melissa Pritchard
Melissa Velasquez
Meredith Hardy
Meredith Lash
Michael DeLozier
Michael Garrity
Michael J. Gustin
Michael Kim
Michael Lindeborg
Michael Zingman
Michelle D
Michelle Morse
Mimi Taufer
Miriam Kaplan
Mishka Terplan
Molly Kirkconnell, MD
Muriel Jean-Jacques, MD
Nabil Saleem
Nancy Agen
Natalia Khosla
Nathalee Kong, MD
Nathan Brooks
Nathan Smith
Neesha Nama
Nicholas Bohrer
Nicholas Hutchings
Nicholas Woolf
Nick Novick
Nick Pickersgill
Nicole Baltrushes Hughes, MD
Nicole Penwill
Nike Mourikes, MD
Nikhil Krishnan
Nitya Sreevalsan
Noreen Singh
Norman Erenrich
Obie Hunt
Oscar Dimant
Pam Silverstein
Pamela Kellogg, MD
Paola Rios
Patricia Raup
Patricia Robertson
Patricia Rush
Patrick Kelley
Patrick Kenney
Paul Gross
Paula Gallagher
Paula Massenaro
Pauline Kuyler
Peter Ladner
Priya Nori
Qianhui Liang
Rachael Latshaw
Rachel Ashton
Rachel Caspar
Rachel Nardin
Rachel Schrier
Rachel Stones
Rajani LaRocca
Rajiv Fernando
Rajyalakshmi Pyda
Rakesh Shah
Raman Singhal
Randi Timerman
Raymond Uymatiao
Rebecca Commito
Rebecca Hofer
Rebecca Lin
Rebecca Mahn
Rebecca Winchester
Rebecca Zuurbier
Renslow Sherer
Reshma Ramachandran
Reuben Baker
Rhiannon Chubb
Rhiannon Talbot
Richard Alleman
Richard Carozza
Richard Gottfried
Richard Weiskopf
Rick Straw
Rita Rossi-Foulkes
Robert Applebaum
Robert Fischoff
Robert H. Barth, MD
Robert Vinetz, MD, FAAP
Robert Wanzek
Robert Zarr, MD
Robin Baltrushes
Robin Herstand
Robin Shriver
Robyn Farmer
Rohan Rastogi
Rolvix Patterson
Ronald Parry
Ronald Sousa
Ronnie Zipkin
Roopa Chari, MD
Rosemary Dixon
Rosemary Dixon
Rupa Shah
Ruth Lesnewski
Sally Moseley
Samantha Chirunomula
Samih Nassif
Sandrijn van Schaik
Sandy Sufian
Santosha Vardhana
Sarah Bourne
Sarah Carpenter
Sarah Fry
Sarah Huertas
Sarah Junker
Sarah Matathia
Sarah McNeil
Sarah Miller, MD, MPH
Sarah Rosenstein
Scott Bloom, MD
Scott Murkin
Sean Heavey
Sekani Allen
Sharon Lee
Shauna Leland
Sheela Maru
Shelley Schimelman
Shilpa Kalluru
Shivang Desai
Simeon Kimmel, MD
Sobia Ansari
Stephanie Bershad, RN
Stephanie Ross
Stephanie Shaw
Stephanie Zheng
Stephen Schultz, MD
Stephen Stabile
Stephen White
Steven Silverstein, MD
Stratos Kantounis, MD
Sudha Reddy
Suhasini Padhi
Surosree Ganguli
Susan McDonald
Susan Rose
Susan Viergever
Susan Willis
Susanne Pinkham
Suzan Preiksat
Suzanne Jantz
Tae Yeon Kim
Taysa Bowers
Terry Zingman
Thomas Duffy
Thomas Maack
Thomas Scary
Thora Reynolds
Thorp Frank K.
Tiffany Cook
Timothy Greene
Timothy Kelly
Timothy Shaw, MD, FACS
Ting Barrow
Tinika Osborne
Tomas Holmlund
Tracy Gutman
Tuhin Roy
Tyler Gray
Van Dang
Vanessa Van Doren
Vaughn Payne
Velandy Manohar
Victoria Caldwell
Vijay Kotecha
Vikash Pernenkil
Vimal Jhaveri, MD
Vivek Ashok
Wayne Shirley
Wendy Kahn, MD
Will Schmitt
William Gross
William Thar
Winthrop DIllaway
Xanthia Tucker
Yama Latif
Yolanda Huet-Vaughn, MD
York Chen
Zadok Sacks
Zaida Garcia
Zane Stampfly
Zarina Silverman
Zinaida Pelkey
Zoe Weinstein